Let me see if I can help you out. Since your network cannot understand "classless" then it means the network is "classful". Classful pertains to the default Class A, B, and C networks. You can still subnet these "classful" networks, but the subnets must be the same throughout.
Now taking the Class B network 188.8.131.52 (not sure where you got classless network) the default mask is 255.255.0.0 or a /16 prefix length. The number of network bits is 16 and the number of host bits is 16. To subnet, we borrow bits from the host portion. If I have 16 bits available what is the largest number of bits I can borrow from 16 to create a new subnet?
I must leave at least 2 bits for hosts in my new subnet. This results in a /30 prefix length. For CCENT or CCNA you will not use the /31 or /32 prefix lengths. You will learn about these at the CCNP level.
So, coming back to the question, we have the following:
network bits = 16
subnet bits = 14
host bits = 2
# of subnets = (2^14) = 16384
# of valid hosts per subnet = (2^2) - 2 = 2
Remember, you can not use the network or broadcast addresses, leaving you only 2 valid hosts in each /30 subnet.
Not sure where they got only 254, but I suspect they only borrowed 8 bits from the host portion, taking the Class B address and making it a /24 or 255.255.255.0 subnet. But this is not the "MAXIMUM" subnets that can be created from a Class B address. The correct answer should be 16,384 subnets.
Thanks for the reply mate. I worked out the answer just as you did.
But the question comes from a book I am required to use to get my Network + certificate. The question is a review question from the chapter dealing with subneting.
"If you worked on an older network that could not interpret classless addressing, and your network ID was 184.108.40.206, what is the theoretical maximum number of different subnets you could create on this network?"
(I assumed the network is only classful because it can't interpret classless addressing)
Answer (according to the publishers): 254
Since you too confirmed the answer I had, 16382 subnets with 2 hosts (2^14 - 2) = 16382, I am beginning to think this is either a complete stuffup on the editors part in the book, or we are both wrong.
16382 subnets with 2 hosts (2^14 - 2) = 16382,.. a complete stuffup on the editors part in the book ?
NO, in the past, we had to subtract 2 from number of subnetts as well as from number of hosts !
Today, unless you have no ip subnet-zero configured on router or you run RIP 1, you do not have to subtract 2 from number of subnetts. this also means you can use subnet zero.
You always subtract 2 from number of Hosts.
As Martin mention in his post above, you subtract 2 when you have "no ip subnet zero". I believe since IOS 12.0, "ip subnet zero" is enabled by default allowing you to now use the all "zero" and all "ones" subnets. So to clarify,
ip subnet zero
# of subnets = (2^14) = 16384
no ip subnet zero
# of subnets = (2^14) - 2 = 16382
either way, the 254 the book has is incorrect. They get 254, by borrowing only 8 bits and assume "no ip subnet zero", so that the # of subnets = (2^8) - 2 = 254.
But this is incorrect, in that you can borrow more than 8 host bits to subnet the Class B address 220.127.116.11.
Hi Brian and Martin,
Yeah, I reakon the book has stuffed up. Found two other questions that have totall wrong answers. I have even contacted the training company that endorses and distributes this book with several examples of my concerns. But as yet have had no reply.
I am currently doing this course through TAFE here in Western Australia. When they come back from our summer break in Feb, I will be contacting my lecturer with my concerns about the quality of this book.
Thanks for your imput guys. You think you must be going mad or just not getting it when no matter how you think about it when your answer is different to a "Professional Training" guide. But when others confirm your suspicions, then you feel a little more confident.
I was excited to find this thread because I have also been wondering about this question. It seems pretty clear from table 9-4 on page 404 of the textbook that a Class B network can have up to 16,382 subnets, even without using supernetting (classless routing). This question might have made more sense if the given network ID was for a Class C network (for example 18.104.22.168), but in that case the answer according to table 9-4 would have been 62 (64), not 254 (256).